The use of world-systems theory to explain the spread of social complexity has become accepted practice by both historians and archaeologists. Gil Stein now offers the first rigorous test of world
systems as a model in archaeology, arguing that the application of world-systems theory to noncapitalist, pre-fifteenth-century societies distorts our understanding of developmental change by
overemphasizing the role of external over internal dynamics. In this new study, Stein proposes two complementary theoretical frameworks for the study of interregional interaction: a
"distance-parity" model, which views world-systems as simply one factor in a broader range of intersocietal relations, and a "trade-diaspora" model, which explains variation in
exchange systems from the perspective of participant groups. He tests his models against the archaeological record of Mesopotamian expansion into the Anatolian highlands during the fourth millennium
B.C. Whereas some scholars have considered this "Uruk expansion" to be one of the earliest documented world-systems, Stein uses data from the site of Hacinebi in southeastern Turkey to
support his alternate perspective. Comparing economic data from pre- and postcontact phases, Stein shows that the Mesopotamians did not dominate the people of this distant periphery. Such
evidence, argues Stein, shows that we must look more closely at the local cultures of peripheries to develop realistic cross-cultural models of variation in colonialism, exchange, and secondary state
formation in ancient societies. By demonstrating that a multitude of factors affect the nature and consequences of intersocietal contacts, his book advocates a much-needed balance between recognizing
that no society can be understood in complete isolation from its neighbors and assuming the primacy of outside contact in a society's development.
A thorough review of Wallerstein's world-system model and its many archaeological applications, Stein's own proposal of alternative models, and a test of the models using data from six excavation seasons at Hacinebi Tepe on the Euphrates River in Turkey. . . . Stein's book should engage the attention of any scholars with interests in interregional interaction in general or world-systems models in particular and represents the state of current research on early state in Mesopotamia. It also presents an ideal model of how to design an excavation and to publish its results.
Journal of Anthropological Research
An outstanding achievement that adds to our understanding of the processes that brought forth the world's first urban literate complexity.
American Historical Review